For those interested in the full text of the Metroland article on McBoydgate, please see full text, below:
Metroland – 8/30/07
Investigation Overload
Surrounded by controversy, Saratoga Springs Comissioner of Public Works Thomas McTygue may now be the subject of an FBI investigation
Saratoga Department of Public Works Commissioner Thomas McTygue is no stranger to controversy, and according to a number of Saratogians who say they have been interviewed by the FBI, McTygue is now the target of an FBI investigation.
At least four sources who wish to remain anonymous out of fear of retribution say they have been interviewed by two FBI special agents about McTygue and his conduct as the commissioner of Public Works. Some of the individuals who claim to have been interviewed have first-hand knowledge of the inner workings of the department. They say that although they are not certain what the subject of the investigation is, they have spoken at length with the FBI about an array of subjects, including McTygue’s dealings with developers, possible misuse of city property and employees, and alleged illegal dumping.
The FBI commented only to say they do not confirm or deny any investigation. Attempts were made to reach McTygue, and a secretary at the Department of Public Works informed Metroland on Tuesday that McTygue would be unreachable that day and the following day because he would be out of town for personal reasons.
According to insiders, at least a dozen people have been interviewed by the FBI regarding McTygue. One source who had been interviewed told Metroland, “Probably about a dozen people have mentioned speaking to the FBI, in passing, but they didn’t want to talk about it in detail. This investigation is not a small one. The agent made it clear that if they had found nothing the investigation would already have ended.”
Another source told Metroland, “I know it’s not just hearsay. It has actually been going on for some time, and they have spoken to numerous people. I know of six people that [the FBI] have had pretty lengthy conversations with, and a couple of them have spoken to the FBI more than once.”
Interviews seem to have started in early 2007 and have occurred as recently as this summer.
Sources said the investigation began as an inquiry to establish the value of an investigation and has now moved on to a second phase.
McTygue simultaneously faces an investigation by the New York State Attorney General’s office and the Department of Environmental Conservation into oil spills at the DPW garage, and possible illegal dumping elsewhere in the city. The status of that investigation is unknown, and it is unclear whether it is related to the FBI’s investigation. However, a number of sources who have been interviewed by the DEC claim to have also been interviewed by the FBI.
The attorney general’s office did not return calls requesting comment.
McTygue supporters have blamed Saratoga Springs Mayor Valerie Keehn for instigating the state investigation and accuse her husband David Keehn, who is a lawyer at the DEC, of having undue influence on the investigations. Keehn denies the charge.
Both the mayor and her challenger, Gordon Boyd, a McTygue ally, claimed to have no knowledge of any investigations. Boyd declined to comment. Keehn, however, said any ongoing investigations “should be allowed to take their course.”
McTygue, a Democrat who has been a longtime powerbroker in Saratoga Springs, has his share of friends and enemies in the city. He has a reputation for ruling his department with an iron fist, while making friends with residents, businesses and developers with his tree-planting program, by repaving sidewalks and providing developers with water hookups. McTygue is credited by conservative pundits with keeping Saratoga beautiful; some even call him the “mayor” of Saratoga Springs.
McTygue’s relationship with Keehn has been venomous.
To his enemies, McTygue is an entrenched member of the old guard who has used his years in office to benefit himself. He is known for holding grudges and punishing his enemies, and is commonly described as a bully.
McTygue has repeatedly fought off charges that he does not meet residency requirements for his position as commissioner. Although naming his legal residence as a small house at 175 Clinton St., McTygue has openly acknowledged living on a large horse farm that features a regulation-sized race track in the Town of Saratoga.
In 2004, McTygue gave up a tax exemption obtained through the state’s STAR program on his Clinton Street property when critics pointed out McTygue did not live there. McTygue did not then apply for the STAR program for his farm. Although the State Board of Elections rejected a challenge to McTygue’s residency earlier this year, saying that his legal residence was in the City of Saratoga, critics of McTygue insist that the fact that he actually lives in the Town of Saratoga Springs violates the City Charter and the State’s Public Officer Law, which say elected officials must be residents of the municipalities they represent.
Former and current DPW workers who wish to remain anonymous alleged that McTygue has been known to have DPW staffers do work on his farm outside of the city, that McTygue used intimidation and threats to ensure that workers would vote for him and his allies whether they lived in the city limits or not, and they further alleged that McTygue has cultivated a relationship with developers that sees them donating large amounts of cash to McTygue’s political causes in exchange for quick water hookups.
“You name it, we discussed it,” said one source of their conversation with the FBI. “The man is crooked as a twisted-up old tree.”
—David King
